_How to Measure Return on Investment (ROI) in PLM for the Defense Sector?
author
Konrad Dróżka
Chief Revenue Office
4 April 2025
Reading time: 9 minutes
Product Lifecycle Management (PLM) is a crucial tool in the defense industry for managing the lifecycle of products—from concept to end-of-life. PLM enables efficient monitoring and optimization of every stage of production and use of military equipment. Given the high costs associated with implementing such systems, accurately measuring Return on Investment (ROI) is essential. This article aims to present methods for assessing ROI in the context of PLM in the defense sector, considering key indicators and factors influencing the effectiveness of such investments.
What is ROI in the Context of PLM?
Return on Investment (ROI) is one of the most important metrics used to evaluate investment efficiency. It represents the ratio of gains to costs incurred, allowing an assessment of how profitable an investment is in terms of achieved benefits. In the case of PLM in the defense sector, ROI primarily refers to savings resulting from process optimization in design, production, maintenance, and equipment operation. Implementing a PLM system can yield benefits in both the short and long term, especially in highly specialized industries such as defense, where products are used for extended periods, and the associated design and manufacturing processes are highly expensive.
In the defense industry, ROI for PLM can encompass various elements, such as reducing design errors, improving operational efficiency, enhancing supply chain control, and optimizing maintenance and servicing processes. All these factors contribute to lower operational costs and increased efficiency, leading to a higher return on investment in PLM.
Key Factors Affecting ROI in PLM
The implementation of PLM in the defense sector impacts various operational aspects that directly influence ROI calculations. Below are some of the most critical factors:
Reduction in Design Costs – PLM improves engineering data organization, reducing the time needed for new product development. Process optimization, task automation, and the elimination of design-phase errors lead to significant cost savings. Shorter project completion times also reduce labor costs and accelerate product market entry.
Increased Production Efficiency – PLM integrates production data and enables better management of the entire manufacturing process. Synchronization between departments allows for identifying and eliminating inefficiencies, while system integration facilitates process automation, reducing errors and associated correction costs. More efficient production also speeds up product manufacturing, reducing order fulfillment times.
Optimization of Logistics and Supply Chain – PLM enables precise tracking of resources, components, and spare parts. This improves inventory management, reduces storage costs, and optimizes delivery processes. Better logistics data management also lowers the risk of delays, which is crucial in the defense industry.
Improved Maintenance and Servicing – Defense products are designed for long-term use. PLM enables comprehensive product history tracking, facilitating maintenance planning and failure prediction. This makes servicing more efficient and minimizes repair costs and downtime.
Enhanced Compliance with Regulations and Standards – The defense sector is subject to strict regulations, and non-compliance can lead to severe legal consequences. PLM helps manage documentation, ensuring full compliance with legal and quality standards, reducing the risk of fines and certification delays.
How to Measure ROI in PLM
To effectively evaluate ROI from PLM implementation, follow these steps for a comprehensive analysis of costs and benefits.
Identifying Investment Costs
The costs of implementing a PLM system cover a broad range of expenses, including:
Software Licenses and IT Infrastructure – Costs of purchasing software and hardware required for PLM operations.
Implementation and Configuration Costs – Adapting the system to company needs and integrating it with existing solutions.
Employee Training – Training personnel to use PLM, which may incur additional costs, especially for complex systems.
Maintenance and Support Costs – Ongoing costs associated with system maintenance and updates.
Business Benefits
The benefits of PLM implementation may include:
Shorter Design Time – Faster prototyping and testing reduce design costs and accelerate product launch.
Reduction in Error Costs – PLM allows for quick detection and correction of design flaws, reducing the cost of later modifications.
Operational Savings – Process optimization, inventory management, and improved logistics management lead to significant cost reductions.
Better Documentation Management – A central data repository enables faster information retrieval and improved document control.
Enhanced Interdepartmental Collaboration – PLM improves communication and information flow between teams, ensuring efficient coordination across the product lifecycle—from design to production, servicing, and disposal.
Assume a defense company invests $5 million in a PLM system, and the savings from process optimization amount to $7.5 million over three years. ROI is calculated as:
This means the company achieved a 50% return on investment within three years.
Challenges in Measuring ROI for PLM in the Defense Industry
While ROI is a crucial metric, measuring PLM investment returns in the defense industry presents several challenges:
Long Product Lifecycles – Military products often have extended lifespans, making it difficult to fully assess PLM benefits until many years later.
Regulatory Changes – Shifting regulations may require system updates, affecting investment efficiency.
System Complexity – Integrating PLM with existing IT solutions and data can be time-consuming and costly, particularly in large organizations.
Measuring ROI in PLM for the defense sector is essential for evaluating investment effectiveness. A thorough analysis of costs and benefits, the application of key performance indicators (KPIs), and consideration of long-term financial aspects allow for a reliable assessment of implementation value. Despite the challenges, a well-planned PLM implementation can lead to significant savings and increased operational efficiency in the defense sector.
The Role of PLM in Risk Management in the Defense Industry
PLM systems play a crucial role in risk management, particularly in the defense sector, which has stringent safety, quality, and data protection requirements. Defense products operate in extreme conditions and are subject to strict regulations, where any design or manufacturing error can lead to costly consequences. PLM enables effective risk management throughout the product lifecycle, from design to operation.
Ensuring compliance with technical and safety regulations is critical in defense. PLM allows real-time monitoring of compliance and early detection of potential design flaws before they become costly problems. Identifying risks in design, production, and operation reduces failures and maintenance costs, improving equipment reliability.
PLM, Sustainability, and Environmental Efficiency
Modern PLM systems contribute to efficient resource and energy management, reducing the environmental footprint of production. Process optimization, material management, and real-time monitoring of raw material consumption allow for significant savings and waste reduction.
Moreover, PLM supports the design of eco-friendly products that are easier to recycle and promotes the use of renewable or biodegradable materials. By controlling product lifecycles, PLM helps defense companies meet environmental regulations while reducing resource and waste management costs, providing both financial and environmental benefits.
Digitization and Automation of Processes in the Context of PLM
Digitization and automation are key elements that make PLM an invaluable tool in the defense industry. The implementation of PLM systems enables full digitization of design, production, and documentation management processes, significantly enhancing operational efficiency. Automated report generation, real-time data analysis, and the introduction of intelligent decision-making algorithms are just a few aspects that help reduce response times and minimize the risk of errors.
Moreover, the automation of decision-making processes—based on the data collected within the system—allows for faster, data-driven decisions rather than relying solely on intuition. By integrating with artificial intelligence (AI) tools, PLM systems can predict equipment failures, leading to significant long-term cost savings by enabling preventive actions in advance. Such automation solutions also help optimize the flow of information within the organization, increasing coherence between project and production teams.
Long-Term Benefits of PLM: How ROI Evolves
It is important to note that the ROI associated with PLM implementation in the defense industry is evolutionary in nature. While initial savings may be visible during the design and production phases—such as reduced project completion time, shorter production cycles, and fewer errors—the full benefits of a PLM system become apparent only during the operational phase. Defense sector products often have long life cycles, meaning that benefits related to maintenance, failure prediction, and efficient resource management will yield savings only after several years.
Data Security and Information Protection in PLM Systems for the Defense Industry
Data security is a top priority in the defense industry, where managing sensitive information related to both projects and technologies is crucial. PLM provides advanced data protection measures such as information encryption, access control, and compliance with regulations governing the protection of sensitive data. These mechanisms help defense industry companies minimize the risk of data leaks and maintain the integrity of production processes.
Transparency in data management, allowing strict tracking and control of information access, is essential for regulatory compliance and minimizing the risk of fraud and errors. In the defense industry, even minor lapses can have serious consequences, making this one of the most critical aspects of implementation.
The Defense Industry and the Future of PLM
As technology advances and efficiency demands grow, PLM systems will become increasingly sophisticated. The future of PLM in the defense sector includes:
Utilization of Artificial Intelligence (AI) – AI enhances PLM data analysis, failure prediction, and decision-making process automation.
Integration with Blockchain Technology – This improves security and transparency in data and product documentation management.
Development of Digital Twins – A full digital representation of a product enables simulation and optimization of operational processes.
Conclusions
Measuring Return on Investment (ROI) in the context of PLM implementation in the defense industry is crucial for assessing the efficiency of expenditures and the benefits achieved. To obtain a comprehensive view of how this technology impacts an organization, a detailed cost-benefit analysis is necessary, taking into account both short-term and long-term aspects. Developing appropriate Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) enables effective monitoring of progress and results in areas such as process optimization, risk management, and operational efficiency.
Measuring ROI in the defense industry is challenging due to the sector’s specific characteristics, including long product life cycles and high technological requirements. Nevertheless, well-planned and effectively implemented PLM systems generate benefits such as improved resource management, failure prediction, and optimized maintenance processes. This, in turn, leads to long-term savings and increased organizational profitability.
Additionally, PLM systems contribute to improved product quality and safety, which is particularly important in the defense sector. They also support operational cost optimization and enable companies to quickly adapt to dynamically changing technological requirements. Ultimately, implementing PLM not only enhances operational efficiency but also strengthens a company’s market competitiveness, making it more flexible and resilient to future challenges.
Proper PLM system implementation not only boosts operational efficiency but also serves as a crucial step in the growth of any company operating in the defense sector.
It is an investment that, in the short term, streamlines and automates processes, and in the long run, provides a solid foundation for company development and scaling. This makes PLM an indispensable tool supporting the achievement of strategic objectives.
PLM in the defense industry – strategic tips for CTO
Main challenges in the defense industry The defense industry faces a range of challenges stemming from both external and internal factors. Understanding these aspects is crucial for effective management, strategic planning, and the implementation of modern PLM tools. External factors and their impact Internal factors as technological and organizational challenges Learn more The defense industry […]
Digital Transformation in the Automotive Industry: How PLM is Revolutionizing the Automotive Sector
The modern automotive industry faces dynamic changes driven by the need to adapt to global technological, environmental, and economic trends. Digital transformation in the automotive sector plays a crucial role in addressing these industry challenges. In this context, Product Lifecycle Management (PLM), empowered by digital transformation, has become an essential tool for implementing modern solutions […]
What does Eco-Design mean and why it’s important to businesses and the environment?
Explore the importance of eco-design for businesses and the environment. Learn how eco-design principles, from material reduction to recyclability, enhance sustainability, reduce costs, and support regulatory compliance, offering a competitive edge in today’s market.
Streamlining Automotive Manufacturing Processes with PTC MPMLink: Understanding Windchill
Optimizing automotive production processes and managing complex supply chains present several challenges in the automotive industry. As the automobile industry advances, particularly with digital twin technology, automakers are seeking more efficient and agile manufacturing solutions to remain competitive in a fast-changing market. The historical evolution of motor vehicles has significantly impacted the automotive industry, especially […]
Navigating through the Systematic Approach of Sustainable Product Design
Sustainable product design encompasses a systematic approach that considers environmental and economic aspects throughout a product’s life cycle. Sustainability and environmental impact have become a fourth key performance indicator (KPI) in product development, joining the traditional metrics of time, cost, and quality. Environmental impacts Adopting a design for sustainability framework positions companies at the forefront […]
Breaking Down Scope 3 Emissions: Best Practices for CSRD Reporting
Uncertain about Scope 3 emissions and the CSRD? This article delves deep, unpacking the importance of sustainable product lifecycles and how ecoPLM empowers businesses to excel in sustainability reporting. Discover how technology is key to transparency and environmental responsibility, taking your business beyond compliance and into a sustainable future.
Sustainable Product Lifecycle Design – Green Innovation Insights
Design for lifecycle sustainability is not just a concept but a necessity in today's environmentally conscious world. By adopting practices aligned with the EcoDesign Directive, utilizing Digital Product Passports, and employing technologies like CCS, industries can significantly reduce their environmental impact. With the support of GreenPLM toolbox, businesses can seamlessly integrate these practices into their operations, paving the way for a sustainable and profitable future.
Designing modular products: The benefit of variant management in PLM
Delve into the world of Modular Design and Product Lifecycle Management (PLM) where Variant Management emerges as a game-changer. Discover how embracing modularity and variant flexibility can lead to enhanced product customization, improved efficiency, and a competitive edge in the market. Unravel the benefits and strategies for implementing successful variant management in your PLM processes, and stay ahead in the dynamic world of product development. Join us in exploring how to revolutionize your approach to product design and management!
Information from various systems within a business is comparable to clues in a criminal case. Every single trace conceals information. Some of them drop out due to a lack of documentation.
Product Lifecycle Management (PLM) – what it is and what makes it essential for the success of a manufacturing company
Product Lifecycle Management (PLM) is by no means a new concept, in fact it has been around since humans started producing things. However, PLM has a different meaning nowadays.
In February 2020, we described how to upgrade Windchill to version 11 step by step. Over a year has passed since that time and a new major version of Windchill – 12 – was released. Today we will show you how to perform an upgrade from Windchill 11 to Windchill 12. Are you ready for Windchill uprade?
Migration from Creo Elements/Direct Model Manager to PTC Windchill – a whim or a necessity?
Product lifecycle management has never been more relevant than it is now, in an ever-changing world. Today, it is no longer enough to have a great idea or even good execution. What is needed now is full control over the product - from concept, through design and production, to service and disposal.
Why is it worth investing in PLM software testing?
Most modern manufacturing companies use PLM systems to document and manage product data. PLM systems support many important operations in a company: first of all – administration of CAD files, documents, and data related to change management. All these functions are permanently updated with new requirements. A small error that occurs in one area can negatively affect whole processes.
Digital Transformation – technological trends for the successful evolution of the automotive industry
The new opportunities associated with Industry 4.0 require companies to adapt to the new environment. In this article, we take a closer look at the current situation in the automotive industry, discuss the challenges it faces and the opportunities offered by digital transformation.
Data Migrations in PLM: how to secure your company’s most important assets – information
Migrating data to a PLM system is often a very complex undertaking, where business environment and ways in which data is being operated on play a key role. A Migration – what is it, what approaches are the most common and what challenges lay ahead of each one? These and more questions are answered in this article.
Change Management in Windchill PDMLink – effective and easy product changes with optimized processes
Process of the product development consists of many steps that are often very complicated, time consuming and not well defined. It is common that companies are struggling to track the progress of the development and keep the documentation up to date. The main challenge that I would like to focus on is the continuous need to improve the product. Because we do not live in the perfect world the changes are unavoidable – whether it is just small fragment of the design that needs to be updated, the part you have been using so far is no longer available or you have to make sure that the product meets the requirements of the new markets.
Brand new capabilities in Windchill 12, the latest version of a well-known PLM system from PTC
Windchill is PTC’s flagship Product Lifecycle Management software, which has its latest version this year - WNC12. The long-announced premiere, scheduled for 2020, was questioned due to the COVID-19 pandemic. But PTC did not disappoint – on 9th June, at the fair in Boston, it announced the release of the latest version of its product lifecycle management (PLM) software. Windchill, which is considered a model example of an Enterprise Class System, has gained new functionalities. What is the potential of the latest, twelfth version of this program? We decided to analyze it for you.
What you should know about Product Lifecycle Management in the Cloud
With Cloud technologies developing rapidly in recent years, so came the thought of using the Cloud for hosting various systems in it, from computationally demanding, through mission critical and more. Product Lifecycle Management (PLM) systems were no different and a large number of both PLM vendors and customers attempted to leverage benefits the Cloud brings to gain that competitive edge world’s best manufacturers always strive for.
Windchill PLM: OOTB, configuration or customization?
Product Lifecycle Management (PLM) vendors promise their systems to be so great, they can be used by organizations from the get-go, revolutionizing how they define and manage their product data. However, that is the case only for those organizations who are willing to adapt their own internal standards and procedures for the sake of pre-implemented best practices within PLM systems.
Computer Aided Design (CAD) techniques have been inseparable from the very dynamic development of industry for many years and their role is growing with every decade. What started as fairly simple systems that functioned basically as virtual drawing boards, has developed over time into packages of advanced IT tools. Although initially they could only be used by select research institutes and the largest and most developed corporations, CAD systems have gradually gained popularity, acquired new functionalities and became easier to use. However, the real revolution took place in the era of fast Internet and Industry 4.0, when CAD systems have dynamically transformed into sophisticated tools integrated with PDM and PLM systems. In addition to the ability to develop a complete 3D representation of a product in a virtual environment, they support virtually all other activities related to the broadly understood design, construction, digital prototyping and preparation of data for other stages of the product life cycle.
8 key capabilities of the PTC Windchill 11 system that will help strengthen the business value of your company
The manufacturing sector is changing faster than ever. The increasing multifaceted nature of processes is associated with maintaining operational efficiency and high quality. The need for transparency and efficiency of operations is increasing and product innovations need to be implemented more and more quickly. Effective planning is the key to the business success of the organisation. In the Industry 4.0 era, IT technologies dedicated to product lifecycle management (PLM) have become even more helpful.
A simple guide to performing a Windchill 10.x upgrade
Still running a Windchill PLM system version 10.0, 10.1 or 10.2? There are several reasons why you should consider upgrading to version 11.1 (or newer).
ALM is an abbreviation of Application Lifecycle Management. As the name shows, the concept was supposed to be used mainly by developers during the process of creating programs. Currently, ALM is widely used in different business fields, where it helps manage a variety of projects. This continuous process of software development can be divided into […]
Upgrade & Migration Team – story about people ideas and the way they evolve in reality
Once upon a time.. Far far away, over a hills and forests… Wait.. Wait.. Wait.. This is not another long fairytale about princesses, castles and dragons without merit or concrete, measurable value. This is a story about pursuing targets and passions. This is a story about people’s ideas and the way they evolve […]
27 000 work hours on PLM projects for the aviation industry tycoon
After four year of contract, Transition Technologies PSC just finished realization of five different projects for huge Brazilian aviation concern. Many hours of hard working… During all of this time our specialist have pended almost 27 000 working hours on the best solutions in PLM, including applications like: PTC Windchill and PTC Integrity Lifecycle […]